Another month and another wine tasting that escalated quickly in planning. The original proposal for a modest BYO event ended in an “Australian Icon” tasting including 1888 and 1908 Seppelt Para Port (to be covered in another post), plus this treasure of Australian wine history.

Just prior to the dinner, a member contacted the rest of us to indicate that he had a problem, a 1944 Seppelt Sparkling Burgundy that he had planned to open later this year had been very lightly leaking and that our assistance was required to drink it as soon as possible.

The wine in question was made by a legend of the Australian wine industry, Colin Preece, who is often mentioned alongside other wine industry luminaries from the early to mid 1900s such as Maurice O’Shea, Max Schubert and Roger Warren. Andrew Caillard MW says that “Preece developed the quintessential Australian Sparkling Burgundy style. He was a hugely influential figure during his time and regarded as one of the most skilful blenders of his generation”. So to try a Sparkling red made by the developer of this style of wine in Australia was an exciting prospect.

These wines are exceptionally rare, in fact I don’t think I’ve seen a Sparkling wine made by Colin Preece at auction in all the time I’ve been interested in wine. The label doesn’t say, but it is likely that the wine was mostly or totally made from Shiraz (despite the Burgundy designation).

There was obviously some concern over the (very minimal) leaking, but the level was still extremely good for a wine of this age. We gathered at the restaurant early to open the bottle as a warm up for the “main” event. The cork broke during opening, but on pouring the wine there was an exciting moment as we saw that there were still very light bubbles and that it was a promising colour with a dark red core fading slightly to an earthy ruby red at the edges.

The nose has layers of complexity with cherry, chocolate, leather, licorice and the red fruit tinged molasses that seems to be a common trait with many of these very old Australian red wines. The palate still carried a tingling frizzante sensation which gave the wine a lift to go with the strongly savoury and earthy flavours.

I left some for as long as I could as the dinner progressed, coming back to it occasionally to find that it was still alive. After a couple of hours it finally started to fade away and I finished the very small amount that I had been able to resist.

This bottle of wine even at 69 years of age lived up to, and even exceeded my expectations and I’m very glad to have had the privilege to try it! I guess it shows why these wines are considered legendary when some lucky bottles continue to show their magic.

Perigord Black Truffle, Hot Foie Gras Jelly, Fleur de Sel

Some photos from a lunch towards the middle of last year at Restaurant Andre in Singapore.

The food and service were both excellent and the value for money at lunch was fairly good at 130 SGD / 100 AUD (plus tax). The wine list was mostly very expensive even compared to Australian prices, so the total cost could very easily blow out with a decent bottle or two.

My favourite courses were the “Imperial Tsar Salmon lightly smoked, tomato and peach salad, basil flower sorbet” which was beautifully plated and had delicate flavours with lots of texture and the basil flower sorbet providing a refreshing element and the “Wild mushroom polenta bianca, 36 hour slow roast short rib beef, potato and onion praune” which didn’t really have a twist, it was just delicious. The dessert course sounded good on paper, but didn’t really come together for me and I thought it was the weakest of the dishes and probably the only misstep.

This was a very strong lunch overall and I left impressed. The dinner menu is supposed to be more ambitious and I would like to try it, but at around 3 times the cost of lunch there are a number of other places I would like to visit first.

The Wine

For the wine, we had a bottle of the David Leclapart Champagne Cuvée l’Amateur NV which had very interesting aromas – lemon, orange peel, flint, green apple and a basil type note to it. The palate was pure, long and poised, with a slender shard of richness prevalent. Great length to it. I really enjoyed this wine and scored it 91/100.

Food Photos

“Snacking” Amuse Bouche
Snacking Amuse Bouche

Imperial Tsar Salmon lightly smoked, tomato and peach salad, basil flower sorbet
Imperial Tsar Salmon lightly smoked, tomato and peach salad, basil flower sorbet

Kaffir Lime Consomme, Baby Leek Ravioli, Carpaccio of Seafood
Kaffir Lime Consomme, Baby Leek Ravioli, Carpaccio of Seafood

Perigord Black Truffle, Hot Foie Gras Jelly, Fleur de Sel
Perigord Black Truffle, Hot Foie Gras Jelly, Fleur de Sel

Wild mushroom polenta bianca, roast chicken, potato and onion praune
Wild mushroom polenta bianca, roast chicken, potato and onion praune

Wild mushroom polenta bianca, 36 hour slow roast short rib beef, potato and onion praune
Wild mushroom polenta bianca, 36 hour slow roast short rib beef, potato and onion praune

Royal chocolate palet “nyangbo”, “beurre noisette” burnt butter ice cream, caramel caocao sponge and textures
Royal chocolate palet

Wines from a dinner at Black by Ezard

Some photos and notes from recent dinner to celebrate a friend’s birthday. Black by Ezard did a great job of hosting us with impressive food and excellent service from the sommelier and team.

SASHIMI of hiramasa kingfish, sesame custard, edamame puree, chardonnay and shallot dressing

SASHIMI of hiramasa kingfish, sesame custard, edamame puree, chardonnay and shallot dressing

ORGANIC FARM EGG potato cream, iberico jamón, herb salad

ORGANIC FARM EGG potato cream, iberico jamón, herb salad

POTATO GNOCCHI handmade, spinach cream, local mushrooms, parmesan, roasted salsify

POTATO GNOCCHI handmade, spinach cream, local mushrooms, parmesan, roasted salsify

OXTAIL soy caramelised, celeriac cream, sichuan peppered enoki, chive and crispy taro salad, mushroom soil

OXTAIL soy caramelised, celeriac cream, sichuan peppered enoki, chive and crispy taro salad, mushroom soil

RUMPCAP grain fed wagyu MBS 9+, buttered désirée puree, marrow and shallot sauce

RUMPCAP grain fed wagyu MBS 9+, buttered désirée puree, marrow and shallot sauce

CHOCOLATE warm couverture ganache, dulce de leche ice cream, peanut butter mousse

CHOCOLATE warm couverture ganache, dulce de leche ice cream, peanut butter mousse

  • 1998 Ployez-Jacquemart Champagne Liesse d’Harbonville – France, Champagne
    Powerful nose – biscuit and coconut, earth, honey and floral notes. The richness on the palate is extremely impressive and it has superb length. Even better than a great bottle a month or so ago. 93/100

  • 2005 Bonneau du Martray Corton-Charlemagne – France, Burgundy, Côte de Beaune, Corton-Charlemagne Grand Cru
    Tightly wound and closed nose, with some pine needle, musk, lemon and talc aromas. The palate is well balanced, with rich fruit and some driven acidity. Give it some time to come together and I think it would be more impressive, though a bottle in May earlier this year was showing as more open and approachable. 91/100

  • 2000 Bonneau du Martray Corton-Charlemagne – France, Burgundy, Côte de Beaune, Corton-Charlemagne Grand Cru
    Pear, peach and slightly honeyed aromas with some nutty oak aromas. The fruit seems to have softened since my last bottle 3 years ago, though it is still quite restrained with good acid cutting through. Another couple of years should serve it well as long as the bottle is sound. 91/100

  • 1999 Domaine de la Vougeraie Musigny – France, Burgundy, Côte de Nuits, Musigny Grand Cru
    Earthy nose as well as black cherries, dark florals, lightly peppery and still showing some oak. Lovely texture on the taut and very well structured palate. Really good stuff, but probably needs another 5-10 years to hit its peak. 92/100

  • 2000 Domaine de la Vougeraie Musigny – France, Burgundy, Côte de Nuits, Musigny Grand Cru
    Earth and truffle aromas as well as some iron and black cherry – there is a smidge of brett as well, but for me it wasn’t dominant or off-putting. Good length to the palate and still has some grip to. Drinking well now and over the next 5 years. 90/100

  • 2001 Jacques-Frédéric Mugnier Musigny – France, Burgundy, Côte de Nuits, Musigny Grand Cru
    A complex nose of cherry, rhubarb, truffle and black tea leaves. The palate is stunningly silken and pure with wonderful length. Improved greatly in the glass, this is a beautiful wine drinking well now but will certainly continue to improve as well. 93/100

  • 2006 Domaine Armand Rousseau Père et Fils Chambertin – France, Burgundy, Côte de Nuits, Chambertin Grand Cru
    Stunningly perfumed – extremely lifted floral notes with complex spices, cherry and earth. Beautifully pristine and extremely bright fruit on the palate with richness, structure and depth. A core of minerality carries the fruit into a amazingly long finish. 95/100

  • 2009 Domaine Armand Rousseau Père et Fils Chambertin-Clos de Bèze – France, Burgundy, Côte de Nuits, Chambertin-Clos de Bèze Grand Cru
    This wine almost left me speechless. The aromas are exhilarating, captivating and unbelievably complex – shifting continually with every inhale – exotic spices, graphite, violets, smoke, tobacco and game. The palate has force through powerful fruit and tannin but there is superb precision and depth to the fruit as well. An incredible wine, maybe the best young red Burgundy I’ve ever tasted. 97/100

  • 1999 Domaine Jean-Louis Chave Hermitage – France, Rhône, Northern Rhône, Hermitage
    Strong kirsch along with earth, pepper and vanilla aromas. The palate is very good indeed, complex and with a lifted freshness through a line of great acidity. Very long and with excellent balance, this will drink well over the next 10-15 years. 93/100

  • 1990 Chris Ringland Shiraz Three Rivers – Australia, South Australia, Barossa, Barossa Range
    Powerful nose of five spice, tar, tobacco, cedar and pencil shavings. Brilliant power on the palate but it doesn’t seem at all over the top, there is balance and brightness to it despite its richness. There are savoury notes that also help balance the very youthful fruit and it finishes with incredible length. Extremely impressive and unbelievably young at 22 years old, this is a monumental wine. 96/100

  • 2001 Zind-Humbrecht Pinot Gris Clos Jebsal Sélection de Grains Nobles – France, Alsace, Alsace AOC
    Orange gold coloured. A rich nose of pineapple, honey, floral notes and peaches and really shows that unique identity of sweet Alsace Pinot Gris. Fleshy and sweet on the palate but with real brightness and acid balance. Some complexity to it, but it disappeared quickly due to being delicious. 94/100

  • 1995 Giuseppe Quintarelli Recioto della Valpolicella Classico – Italy, Veneto, Valpolicella, Recioto della Valpolicella Classico
    Compelling and unbelievably rich nose of kirsch, raisin, tobacco, dark chocolate, blackcurrant and tar. The palate is just incredible in its balance between sweetness, deeply rich fruit and acidity. Intense and mouth-filling but somehow superbly drinkable at the same time. This wine was right at the very top level, what an experience! 97/100

978H5080-L.jpg

I was fortunate a few weekends ago to finally try a wine from the revered Australian winemaker, Maurice O’Shea.

O’Shea is regarded as a master and pioneer of the winemaking craft in Australia and his best wines still have the potential to be great, despite the basic conditions under which they were made.

The wines range from the 1920s to the mid 1950s when O’Shea passed away and are incredibly rare, many were made from a single barrel (resulting in around 200 cases production) and obviously as time goes on the number of bottles available diminishes either due to cork failure and oxidization or their consumption. Even fewer become available to purchase as well, since those lucky enough to have any bottles hold them very closely.

Earlier this year a bottle of the 1952 “Stephen Hermitage” came up at auction. The level was quite low, around mid-shoulder, so there was some risk involved. Some members of a wine group I’m involved with were interested and we split the cost to minimise our exposure. We ended up getting the bottle for a very reasonable price.

There is very little information that I’ve found available about the wine, but it is from the Hunter Valley region and probably made from mostly Shiraz grapes. 1952 was regarded as a good vintage in between 2 lacklustre years in 1951 and 1953.

We opened the wine just before serving and the cork was soaked through and in poor shape. The colour was great for a 60 year old wine, maroon in the middle and fading away toward the edges. The nose was very much in the style of great Hunter Valley Shiraz – leather and earth with tobacco, cherry and some of that brown sugar character that these old wines can take on. The palate is alive with sweet old red fruit that carried across the length of the wine and some integrated acidity to give it drive. The flavours held and didn’t fade away in the hour that we spent with it. The condition was all we could have hoped for – it isn’t the very greatest old wine I’ve had, but it was still a great old wine – true to its place and maker and an experience to remember.

As for the other wines, they were a mixed bag, in fact our strike rate with old wine was well down on normal – but overall it was a truly memorable lunch.

  • NV Demarne-Frison Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut Nature Lalore – France, Champagne, Côte des Bars (Aube), Champagne
    From 2009 fruit, disgorged October 2011. This was served slightly warm but was still appealing with biscuity aromas, floral notes and some oyster shell character. The palate has nicely clean acid and good persistence. Should improve with a couple of years in bottle. 90/100

  • NV Demarne-Frison Champagne Goustan Brut Nature – France, Champagne, Côte des Bars (Aube), Champagne
    From 2009 fruit, disgorged October 2011. There was some citrus and more earthy character on the nose. Tasted next to the same release of the Blanc de Blancs, this had more driven power and body, but also crackling acidity. Consistent with a previous bottle. 91/100

  • 2009 Vouette et Sorbée Champagne Cuvée Fidèle Extra Brut – France, Champagne
    Just had a small pour of this but it still left a good impression. Intense cherry, pear and floral notes on the nose. The palate has a flavour profile that is bursting with richness and intensity. Very good length. 91/100

  • 1988 Pipers Brook Vineyard Riesling – Australia, Tasmania
    Still golden coloured. The nose has plenty of attraction with honey, lots of toast and some kerosene (which I happen to enjoy). The palate has some decent honeyed fruit left, though it finishes a little bit short. This was holding up well for a 24 year old Tasmanian Riesling! 88/100

  • 1998 Tyrrell’s Sémillon Vat 1 – Australia, New South Wales, Hunter Valley
    Much more developed than a great bottle earlier this year, with buttered popcorn, wax and lime. The palate has good length and retains some of the acid line I remember on the previous bottle, but this one was ready to drink now and unlikely to improve. 90/100

  • 1973 Ferdinand Pieroth Guldentaler Schloßkapelle Auslese – Germany, Rheinhessen
    No grape type listed on the label, so a slight mystery. The nose has aromas of grapefruit, ginger and honey. The palate has an interesting texture and I liked it but it fades away just too early. 87/100

  • 2008 Benoit Ente Puligny-Montrachet 1er Cru Les Champs-Gain – France, Burgundy, Côte de Beaune, Puligny-Montrachet 1er Cru
    My favourite of the three white burgundy on the day. Slate, lemon and orange zest on the nose. The palate is restrained and driven by beautiful minerality, with a backbone of fine acidity. 90/100

  • 2009 Michel Tessier Meursault 1er Cru Poruzots Dessus – France, Burgundy, Côte de Beaune, Meursault 1er Cru
    Lots of banana/ester character on the nose with some light florals coming through with effort. The palate has a nice splash of richness and good structure but the nose is tough to get past right now. 88/100

  • 2007 Jean-Philippe Fichet Puligny-Montrachet 1er Cru Les Referts – France, Burgundy, Côte de Beaune, Puligny-Montrachet 1er Cru
    Smothered in oak, there are some pine needles and melon as well. The palate is of a similar ilk, though some fruit is peeking out in the background. I found it a difficult wine to enjoy now, maybe some time will help but I’m not sure. 86/100

  • 2009 Sadie Family Palladius – South Africa, Coastal Region, Swartland, Malmesbury
    Nutty, lemon, pear and smoky aromas. Complex and rich on the palate, there is great structure and acidity. Some at the table found that the alcohol was a bit too prominent but for me it didn’t distract. 91/100

  • 1976 Jean Sanders Echezeaux – France, Burgundy, Côte de Nuits, Echezeaux Grand Cru
    From a Bordeaux (Barsac) negociant house. Swampy, hoisin and wet soil aromas, I thought it might blow off but it got worse and then quickly fell over. I was brave enough to taste it and it was short and had no depth. NR/100

  • 1963 Wynns Coonawarra Estate Hermitage – Australia, South Australia, Limestone Coast, Coonawarra
    Cedar, raspberry and some caramel notes on the nose. Palate still has some tannin and grip, it is decent to drink and has some elements of interest but it is fading away and past its best. 87/100

  • 1968 Penfolds HV/SA Bin 333 – Australia, South Australia
    The aromas are promising with mint, earth and coconut. The palate however is flat and much too short. Well past its peak. 82/100

  • 1968 Hardys Shiraz Reserve Bin C715 Burgundy – Australia, South Australia
    Cherry, ground coffee and some nail polish remover (though some found it more prominent than others). The palate had some decent red fruit initially, but this dropped away quickly after pouring leaving it flat. Another wine without enough life. 83/100

  • 1952 Giacomo Borgogno & Figli Barolo Riserva – Italy, Piedmont, Langhe, Barolo
    Liquorice and cherry, with leather and some bacon aromas. Palate still has some bright fruit and both tannin and acid are present and are well balanced. Really nice drinking, though I didn’t find it incredibly complex. 90/100

  • 1977 Lake’s Folly Cabernet Sauvignon – Australia, New South Wales, Hunter Valley
    Totally gone. NR/100

  • 1986 Henschke Shiraz Mount Edelstone – Australia, South Australia, Barossa, Eden Valley
    Almost seemed more Cabernet in style with capsicum, raspberry and mint aromas. The palate has beautiful soft red fruits and great balance. Fully mature and delicious. 91/100

  • 2000 Gaja Barbaresco – Italy, Piedmont, Langhe, Barbaresco
    Poured without a decant and even though it has appeal straight away, it really started to soar with time in the glass. Cherry and graphite, pencil shavings and cherry, with floral notes entwined. Structurally excellent, with super length. In 7-8 years it should be on another level. 93/100

  • 2009 Motörhead Shiraz – Australia, South Eastern
    Cherry, blackcurrant and blackberry on the nose. Lively red fruit on the palate with some good power to it. Better than expected and a pleasant dose of fruit after a run of wines that were past their best. 88/100

  • 2008 Sadie Family Columella – South Africa, Coastal Region, Swartland
    Tobacco, raspberry, cherry and blackberry. Bright and vibrant fruit on the palate with great persistence and coiled power. Lovely wine that is drinking well already but another 10 years should serve it well. 91/100

  • 1985 Niederthäler Hof Munsterer Liebeholl Bacchus Beerenauslese – Germany, Nahe
    Tropical fruits – pineapple and quince with nutty and vanilla elements. Palate is round but not as rich as expected. Fairly low in acidity but tasty. 89/100

  • 1969 Seppelt Ondenc GW 88 Sauternes – Australia, New South Wales
    Lime and ginger with honey and sugar. The palate is holding up well, there is a touch of sweetness and some cleansing acidity. It could be said that it is not overly long but it’s in much better shape than I thought it would be. 88/100

  • NV Scanavino Moscato d’Asti – Italy, Piedmont, Asti, Moscato d’Asti
    From 2012 fruit, a quick palate cleanser. Grape, musk and floral notes. There is a fair amount of sweetness but good countering acidity. I should buy some for summer drinking. 89/100

Thousand Candles 2011 Shiraz

I recently attended a dinner with winemaker William Downie at The Oak Barrel in Sydney. He has built a solid reputation for his Pinot Noir, first at De Bortoli and then starting in 2003 with his small production self-named label.

Recently he has attracted further attention as the winemaker for the “Thousand Candles” project (label pictured above). The first release of this wine is primarily Shiraz, with a splash of Pinot Noir and a pinch of barrel-fermented Sauvignon Blanc! The wine has received some glowing reviews and generated a great deal of discussion over its $100 price point, a tough ask for the first vintage of a potentially challenging wine.

The dinner was a great opportunity to try the initial releases of the Yarra Valley Pinot Noir, the first vintage from the Mornington Peninsula (2006) as well as the aforementioned Thousand Candles.

Being a small dinner, there was plenty of opportunity to speak to William throughout the night and I found him to be humble but also passionate about what he is doing. He spoke fondly about the time he spent in Burgundy during the 2003-2005 vintages and I think the wines we tasted are a good reflection of his desire to represent the sites where they are grown.

  • NV Laherte Frères Champagne Les Clos – France, Champagne
    Served on arrival. Green apple and pear with some slight florals as it warms up. With piercing acid, it is very clean but there is not much more to the palate. 87/100

  • 2003 William Downie Pinot Noir – Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Yarra Valley
    150 cases produced. Nicely complex aromatics of dark cherries, autumn leaves and a little splash of spice. There is some mint after time in the glass. Still lively on the palate with good complexity, it is right in the zone for drinking from now to 2014. 89/100

  • 2004 William Downie Pinot Noir – Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Yarra Valley
    Aromas of red cherries, earth and a touch of stemmy character. The medium bodied palate is impressive, with excellent acid and texture, finishing with persistence. Has really opened up since I tried it a couple of years ago. Drink now – 2016. 90/100

  • 2005 William Downie Pinot Noir – Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Yarra Valley
    Dark floral aromas in the violet spectrum with smoky meaty elements and light oak. Very bright and lifted palate, it is deliciously appealing and has very good length. Drink 2014-2019. 91/100

  • 2006 William Downie Pinot Noir – Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Yarra Valley
    Rosewater, red cherry and raspberry aromas. Red fruit drives the palate, there is good depth, maybe just needing a touch more acidity to be really great. Should drink well over the next 5-6 years. 90/100

  • 2006 William Downie Pinot Noir – Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Mornington Peninsula
    This was tasted next to the 2006 Yarra Valley and they underwent the same vinification process – there is a clear regional difference evident. Aromas of mocha, dark floral notes, cinnamon and earth, Rich and deep on the palate, with great length and texture. Really very good. Drink over the next 6-8 years. 92/100

  • 2007 William Downie Pinot Noir – Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Yarra Valley
    Stalks, violets and earth with some raspberry and smoke. There is generosity of bright red fruit flavour on the palate without being too forceful. Good length and good potential. 91/100

  • 2011 William Downie Pinot Noir – Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Yarra Valley
    Interesting nose of vanilla, iron and graphite. Palate has nice texture and good length. The balance is there as well and it has potential to improve over the medium term. 90/100

  • 2011 William Downie Pinot Noir – Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Mornington Peninsula
    Cloudy coloured. Appealing nose with soft florals and strawberry marshmallows. The palate has acid prominent right now but there is some fruit depth as well. Needs a couple of years to settle down in bottle. 88/100

  • 2011 William Downie Pinot Noir – Australia, Victoria, Gippsland
    Cloudy coloured. Perfumed raspberry, some chocolate and cherry with earth in the background. Balanced and restrained on the palate, it has the acid and structure to age reasonably well over 4-5 years. 90/100

  • 2011 Thousand Candles – Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Yarra Valley
    A combination of 92% Shiraz, 6% Pinot Noir and 2% Sauvignon Blanc. Controversial and interesting nose of pepper, sap, cherry, raspberry, vanilla and grass. The palate is less in dispute, it is clearly very good – balanced with silky restrained fruit, spice and savoury earth. Textured and long. It took me a while to come around to this wine, but in the end I found myself liking it more each time I thought about it. 91/100

  • 2009 William Downie Petit Manseng – Australia, Victoria, North East, King Valley
    Mango, peach, apple and strawberry. Palate is medium sweetness (around 50 grams per litre residual sugar) with good acid and decent length. It isn’t overly deep but it is appealingly tasty. 89/100

This dinner was organised by Shannon from Rare Wine Dinners, with the focus this time on German Riesling plus White and Red Rioja. The event was held at Rise in Sydney, a small Japanese Restaurant that did a good job with the demands of serving this much wine to a full restaurant over the course of the evening. Thanks must go to Shannon for the careful sourcing and planning that goes into running these dinners.

A few very short notes from me follow;

  • 2009 Schloss Vaux Rheingau Riesling Brut – Germany, Rheingau
    Floral, stonefruit and mineral nose. Palate has a burst of acidity and is quite fresh, but there is a lack of depth and interest. 85/100

  • 2011 Freiherr Langwerth von Simmern Hattenheimer Nußbrunnen Riesling Kabinett trocken – Germany, Rheingau
    Light floral notes, with some spice and citrus. Very light richness on the palate. Simple but quite tasty. 88/100

  • 1998 Hessische Staatsweingüter Kloster Eberbach Steinberger Riesling Goldkapsel – Germany, Rheingau
    Grapefruit and marmalade with some orange peel. Drops away too quickly on the palate for my liking, there is a touch of sweetness but not much else. This has aged but not really developed any complexity. 85/100

  • 2011 Freiherr Langwerth von Simmern Rauenthaler Rothenberg Riesling Spätlese – Germany, Rheingau
    Lime, smoke and honeysuckle aromas. Intense sweetness on the palate, I find that there isn’t enough acidity or brightness to cover for it and it ends feeling unbalanced. 83/100

  • 1976 Freiherr Langwerth von Simmern Rauenthaler Rothenberg Riesling Spätlese – Germany, Rheingau
    Kumquat, apple, straw and light smoke. Good acidity brightens the palate. Good length and there is some depth evident. Drink now. 89/100

  • 1964 Joh. Jos. Prüm Wehlener Zeltinger Sonnenuhr Riesling Auslese – Germany, Mosel Saar Ruwer
    Amazing light straw gold colour. Enticing aromas of florals, lemon, talc and some spices. The nose was consistent over an hour or more, not dropping away but not unfurling further either. Palate is a highlight with excellent balance and imposing length – subtle initially it just builds superbly across the mid-palate and holds on for quite some time. 92/100

  • 1981 R. López de Heredia Rioja Blanco Reserva Viña Tondonia – Spain, La Rioja, La Rioja Alta, Rioja
    Caramel, vanilla and lemon with a little bit of nutty oxidative character (but not as much as I expected). Texturally it was very interesting, though the acid was a touch prickly on the finish. 88/100

  • 2011 Freiherr Langwerth von Simmern Erbacher Marcobrunn Riesling Kabinett – Germany, Rheingau
    Lots of sulphur here, there is some white flowers and honey after time. Rich and youthful on the palate, it has just enough acid to carry the sweetness. 89/100

  • 1976 Georg Müller Stiftung Hattenheimer Deutelsberg Riesling Auslese – Germany, Rheingau
    Some aromas in the eucalypt/mint spectrum as well as marmalade and melting sugar. Great balance and depth, the components woven together with purpose. Drinking well now but will hold for quite some time. 91/100

  • 1959 August Eser Oestricher Lenchen Riesling Spätlese – Germany, Rheingau
    Honey, grapefruit and coconut aromas. Beautifully balanced on the palate, light richness and a good core of acidity persisting. Great length and a real pleasure to drink. 92/100

  • 1994 Martinez Bujanda Rioja Reserva – Spain, La Rioja, La Rioja Alta, Rioja
    Graphite, leather, strawberry, aniseed and some kirsch. Some balanced savoury intensity on the palate with good length. Mostly resolved and ready to drink, I preferred this to the 95 Finca Valpiedra Reserva served by its side. 90/100

  • 1995 Martinez Bujanda Rioja Finca Valpiedra Reserva – Spain, La Rioja, La Rioja Alta, Rioja
    Interesting aromas of stewed plum, charcoal, orange rind and some brett influence. Tannins still standing out on the palate, there is some red fruited character in behind but not much depth. Maybe another 3-4 years would help this wine round out its edges a little bit. 88/100

  • 1975 Bodegas Valdemar (Martinez Bujanda) Rioja Conde de Valdemar Gran Reserva – Spain, La Rioja, La Rioja Alta, Rioja
    Was served two bottles of this, the second blind. The first showed spice, cedar and caramelised fruit. The palate was holding up okay, with some grip from tannins but fades away on the finish. 87/100

  • 1983 La Rioja Alta Rioja Gran Reserva 904 – Spain, La Rioja, La Rioja Alta, Rioja
    Complex and compelling aromas of autumn leaves, cherry, smoky leather, tobacco and spices. Beautifully balanced palate, there is sweet old fruit with earthy savoury notes. Detailed, textured and very long. Fantastic. 93/100

  • 1976 Niederthäler Hof Bochinger Bischofskreuz Riesling Beerenauslese – Germany, Pfalz
    Apple, ginger, candied apricot and sultana aromas. Acidity still in tact provides good drive through the medium sweetness on the palate. Good length with some depth to it as well. 90/100

  • 1975 Bodegas Valdemar (Martinez Bujanda) Rioja Conde de Valdemar Gran Reserva – Spain, La Rioja, La Rioja Alta, Rioja
    The second bottle was fresher with the same spice and cedar, but also some earth and cherry. The red fruit is more evident on the palate as well but there still isn’t great complexity. 88/100

Dominique Laurent Bonnes Mares

A few brief notes and photos on a recent dinner at Otto Ristorante in Sydney. The event was a charity dinner for Walk, Talk, Fly with 6 well known local chefs each providing a pasta dish and BYO encouraged.

We had some excellent wines, the food was mostly very good and as usual it was a fun night with this group.

The Wines

  • 1995 Lanson Champagne Brut Noble Cuvée de Lanson – France, Champagne
    From magnum. Oyster shell, green apple and lemon on the nose. Palate shows the typical high acid Lanson style, but there is some light fruit richness to balance this out. Give it 10 more years. 91/100

  • 2010 Pieropan Soave – Italy, Veneto, Soave
    Light spice and nutty aromas with some waxy notes in the background. The palate is medium weighted with interesting textural elements. Medium length and quite tasty. 89/100

  • 1996 McWilliam’s Mount Pleasant Wines Sémillon Lovedale – Australia, New South Wales, Hunter Valley
    Served blind. Lanolin and lime with honey and a touch of smoke. Palate has weighty honeyed fruit but also has the acidity to finish cleanly. Drinking at its peak. This is the second great bottle I’ve had in the past couple of years, with a less impressive bottle in between. 92/100

  • 2000 Tyrrell’s Chardonnay Vat 47 – Australia, New South Wales, Hunter Valley
    Served blind. A rich and aged nose of caramel, honey and butterscotch. Palate is very much richly weighted as well though there is still good drive and length. More advanced than a bottle last year, but still very good. 90/100

  • 2009 Bass Phillip Chardonnay Premium – Australia, Victoria, Gippsland
    Lemon, some sea spray and a little wild earth character, the nose opened and improved the longer the wine was in the glass. The palate is classy, with oak and fruit in balance and appealing length. I’d like to see this again in 3-4 years. 90/100

  • 2007 Michel Picard Corton-Charlemagne – France, Burgundy, Côte de Beaune, Corton-Charlemagne Grand Cru
    Flint and mineral on the nose, with lemon, oats and lilies in support. Rich fruit that really takes off on the mid-palate and finishes long. Very youthful but still has character and is delicious. 92/100

  • 2000 Dominique Laurent Bonnes Mares – France, Burgundy, Côte de Nuits, Bonnes Mares Grand Cru
    Really lovely complex aromatics here – strawberry, game, floral notes, light smoke and earth. Palate is bold but has detail as well, with both savoury red and deeply set black fruit elements. There is very good tannin structure and good length. Being a 2000 I had thought it may be near its peak, but I think this safely has another 5-6 years to get there. 92/100

  • 2002 Dry River Syrah Lovat – New Zealand, North Island, Wairarapa, Martinborough
    Black pepper on the nose with stems and some meaty aromas. The palate shows great restraint with more spice and pepper elements evident. Pleasingly detailed texture provides extra interest. For me I thought this was drinking well now and should continue to do so over the next few years. 90/100

  • 2008 Freeman Vineyards Secco Corvina Rondinella – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Hilltops
    Blackcurrant, cherry and liquorice with some szechuan pepper aromas. The tannin and bold black fruits mingle well on the palate, giving the impression of both richness and structure. I’m sure I’ve had a previous vintage of this but I can’t find my note – I remember liking whatever vintage that was and I liked this one too! 89/100

  • 1991 Henschke Cyril Henschke – Australia, South Australia, Barossa, Eden Valley
    Served blind. The nose is excellent – with leather, redcurrant, tobacco and still some signs of vanilla oak. Deliciously smooth and resolved on the palate, with balance and complexity – this has really progressed well over the past 7 years since I last tasted it. Drink over the next 4-5 years. 91/100

  • 1990 Penfolds Bin 389 – Australia, South Australia
    Intense nose of tobacco, blackberry, graphite and cocoa. Palate is extremely youthful still, there is plenty of dark fruit and fine but evident tannin. Another 5+ years wouldn’t have done this bottle any harm. 91/100

  • 2010 Cascina Degli Ulivi Semplicemente Triple A Vino da Tavola – Italy, Vino da Tavola
    Violets, cherry and strawberry aromas with some horsy notes as well. The palate is lightweight and has quite nice acidity. Drink now. 87/100

  • 2004 Giacomo Brezza & Figli Barolo Sarmassa – Italy, Piedmont, Langhe, Barolo
    The nose was closed and tight initially, with some time there was tar and fresh pine needles then some nicely perfumed floral notes. The tannins were at the fore on the palate. While there is not great complexity just yet, it should come with some extended time in bottle. 90/100

  • 2001 Pian Delle Vigne (Antinori) Brunello di Montalcino – Italy, Tuscany, Montalcino, Brunello di Montalcino
    Appealing nose with raspberry and cherry, tobacco and tar with a little touch of earth.The palate has a plush softness to it but there is excellent depth as well. Balanced and already drinking well. 92/100

  • 1971 Château Broustet – France, Bordeaux, Sauternais, Barsac
    Honey, orange peel, toffee and butterscotch on the nose. Palate still shows vibrancy and balance against the medium sweetness. Very good. 90/100

The Food

Joe Camilleri – Beppi’s
Spinach pasta rolled with lemon mascarpone, smoked salmon, salsa verde with ocean trout caviar micro herbs & basil

978H3661-M.jpg

Danny Russo – The Old Library
Squid ink Tortellini filled with crab meat & mascarpone, tomato, lemon caper sauce

978H3692-M.jpg

Giovanni Pilu – Pilu at Freshwater
Malloreddus, guanciale, bottarga & crispy Sardinian bread

978H3702-M.jpg

Eugenio Maiale – A Tavola
Roast pumpkin filled triangoli, sage butter, poppy seeds

978H3719-M.jpg

Alessandro Pavoni – Ormeggio
Carnaroli Risotto beetroot and Gorgonzola

978H3767-M.jpg

Richard Ptacnik – Otto Ristorante
Chestnut strozzapreti with braised rabbit, pancetta, olives, thyme

978H3782-M.jpg

A recent visit to 5 cellar doors in the Canberra District wine region.

Clonakilla

Clonakilla is one of my favourite wineries in Australia and I will often try to time a trip down to Canberra to coincide with the release of the new vintage of their flagship Shiraz Viognier each September. The cellar door is functional but seems a little bit dated now, I am also ever hopeful of them switching to better glassware than the standard ISOs (many places are now using restaurant range Riedels or similar) but it hasn’t happened yet and it seems like a simple change that could really help the wines (and the experience).

The wines were fairly solid across the range as usual, however the Shiraz Viognier I think suffers from the difficult 2011 vintage and I will probably allow my decent vertical collection to be broken. It is by no means a bad wine, it just isn’t worth $85 and I actually preferred the $35 O’Riada.

  • 2012 Clonakilla Semillon / Sauvignon Blanc – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Light herbs, floral and citrus notes – nicely aromatic. Good acidity on the palate and pretty appealing overall for drinking now. 89/100

  • 2012 Clonakilla Riesling – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Nicely floral nose with green apples as well. Palate is strongly acidity driven and bright. Good and will get better, but I can’t see it being great. 88/100

  • 2011 Clonakilla Viognier Nouveau – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Citrus, apple and light apricot on the nose. The palate is uncomplicated, though it hints at decent texture. 87/100

  • 2011 Clonakilla Viognier – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Peach, spice and lemon with some wild barrel character in the background. The palate give the initial impression of roundness, but there is good acidity to lift the wine. Texturally interesting as well. 90/100

  • 2011 Clonakilla Shiraz Hilltops – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Hilltops
    I liked the nose, with floral and cherry notes and a touch of game. The palate is simple and there is a stalky character to it, with little depth. 86/100

  • 2011 Clonakilla Shiraz O’Riada – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Very appealing nose of pepper, violets, spice and bright red cherries. The palate has that floral lift to it as well but there is some spice and good depth also. Really good and I currently prefer it to the Shiraz Viognier in this vintage. 90/100

  • 2011 Clonakilla Shiraz Viognier – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Very light pepper, with mint, cedar and cherry. The mint note appears on the palate as well, the length is alright but it just feels like it is lacking in drive and complexity. It’s still good but I feel like it will be at its best over the next 5-7 years. 88/100

Eden Road Wines

Next stop was Eden Road Wines. I haven’t visited this producer before but had heard good things and decided it was time to try the range. Last year they purchased and moved into the large Doonkuna cellar door, which is conveniently close to Clonakilla. The cellar door did feel a bit bit too big, especially as we were the only people there at the time but a positive was the plentiful natural light.

I was really quite impressed by the overall quality of the wines here, the top Chardonnay (Tumbarumba & Courabyra) and Shiraz (Hilltops, Canberra, Gundagai) are moving into fairly expensive territory (between $36 and $50) but I quite liked The Long Road range, especially the Chardonnay, at around $20. I believe the majority of the grapes are sourced from growers, but with the purchase of Doonkuna they acquired ownership of some additional vineyard area. I’ll definitely revisit here next time and I’m looking forward to trying this range again.

  • 2011 Eden Road Pinot Gris – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Spice, some lemon peel, pear and peaches. The palate has an oily Alsace styled mouthfeel to it, with good length and finishes clean due to the acid line. 89/100

  • 2010 Eden Road Riesling The Long Road – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Grapefruit and soft floral aromas, backed by a touch of slate. The palate is mineral driven with a good core acid profile. Well balanced. 89/100

  • 2011 Eden Road Chardonnay The Long Road – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Tumbarumba
    Green apple, oats and pear aromas on the nose. The palate shows pure fruit and a minerality reminiscent of good Chablis. I found this to be delicious and great value, I actually slightly preferred it to the two more expensive Chardonnay tried from this producer. 90/100

  • 2011 Eden Road Chardonnay Tumbarumba – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Tumbarumba
    Graphite, mandarin, light oak and pear on the nose. Palate shows restraint with nicely bright citrus fruit though there is an ever so slight roundness to the edges. Finishes with good length. 89/100

  • 2011 Eden Road Chardonnay Courabyra – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Tumbarumba
    Lemon, slate and a touch of oak influence. Palate is medium bodied and there is just a pinch of rich fruit showing through. Good, but I think it will lift further with a couple of years in bottle. 88/100

  • 2012 Eden Road Riesling Off-Dry Canberra – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Peaches, pear and light spice aromas. Pushes the limits of reasonably calling it off-dry, with 28 grams per litre of residual sugar without quite having the level of acidity needed to lift and focus the wine. Still quite tasty though. 87/100

  • 2011 Eden Road Pinot Noir – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Tumbarumba
    Lightly scented nose of cherry, olive and stalk. The palate is also best described as light, though there is some mid palate texture to give it some interest. 87/100

  • 2010 Eden Road Shiraz The Long Road – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Lifted aromas of red cherry, liquorice and a small pinch of spice. The palate is medium bodied with a good balance of red fruit and some pepper/spice. Will be nice to drink over the short-medium term. 88/100

  • 2010 Eden Road Shiraz Hilltops – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Hilltops
    Aromatic bright floral notes, red berries, cherry and pepper on the nose. The palate gives off more of a dark fruit impression with good depth and restraint. Very enjoyable. 90/100

  • 2011 Eden Road Shiraz Canberra – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Floral nose with spice, stalk and some blueberry undercurrents. There is plenty of interest on the palate, good depth and restrained savoury fruit – right along the lines of the style I like. 90/100

  • 2011 Eden Road Shiraz Gundagai – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Gundagi
    Black cherry, liquorice, dark chocolate and graphite. Excellent savoury mouthfeel with some medium bodied dark fruit supporting. Textured and long, really quite impressive. 91/100

Helm

Helm is another producer I really admire in the Canberra region. From visits over a number of years I think that the Riesling here is some of the best in Australia, however the wines tasted this time were just slightly below expectations (still mostly good though), apart from the 2010 Premium which was great. The cellar door in a tiny 1888 school house is charming, and it is also a nice place to stop for a picnic lunch as there are tables and chairs scattered around the vineyard outside.

  • 2011 Helm Riesling Classic Dry – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Floral and aromatic nose with some lemon and lime. Good acid profile on the palate, a touch more depth to the fruit would be nice though. I prefer the 2010 and 2009 but this was still pleasant. 88/100

  • 2010 Helm Riesling Premium – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Lemon, light florals and slate on the nose. Shines on the palate – precise, balanced and focused on the palate, with drive and persistence. I loved the 08 and 09 versions of this wine and I can see a trend developing. 91/100

  • 2009 Helm Sauvignon Blanc – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Olives and lemon on the nose. Palate is medium bodied with some grip and a slightly oily texture to it. Interesting but not necessarily enjoyable. 87/100

  • 2012 Helm Riesling Half Dry – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Passionfruit and orange peel on the nose. Residual sugar is noticeable and if I had to guess would be around 15 grams per litre – though there is decent balance with the acidity. Could do with some more complexity but it is superficially nice to drink. 88/100

  • 2012 Helm Riesling Botrytis – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Lemon peel and honey on the nose. The richness and the sweetness come in over the top of the acid line and while it doesn’t end up as cloying, it doesn’t have enough drive for my taste. I wanted to like this more but it wasn’t as good as I hoped. 86/100

  • 2009 Helm Cabernet Sauvignon – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Mint and menthol with light liquorice aromas. Medium bodied with decent length, but fails to provide nearly enough depth. Fine to drink but there are so many more interesting options available. 85/100

  • 2008 Helm Cabernet Sauvignon Premium – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Plum, licorice and game aromas. Palate is medium bodied and suitably balanced between ripeness and restraint. Balance is fine, there is just some excitement lacking here. 88/100

  • 2008 Helm Cabernet Shiraz – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Chocolate, spices, liquorice and light mint on the nose. Medium bodied and nicely balanced, there are some nice textural elements here. The Cabernet fruit is from the same source as the 2008 Premium bottling and the addition of the Shiraz component give it more depth and interest. 89/100

Capital Wines

I’ve been waiting for the cellar door at Capital Wines to be ready for the last few years and this year it was finally completed. It is located in reconstructed stables next to their well regarded Grazing restaurant which would also be a good place to stop for lunch if in the area. The reconstruction has been done quite well and there is a good mix of rustic elements and modern touches.

Overall this was a consistently strong lineup of wines, with the Reserve Merlot especially exciting.

  • 2010 Capital Wines Chardonnay The Senator Kyeema – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Lemon butter, some wheat and peach. Rounded palate, probably a bit too rounded for my taste but there is some texture to give it a little bit of interest. 87/100

  • 2011 Capital Wines Chardonnay Viognier Kyeema Canberra District – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Quince, peach and apricot on the nose. Lusciously textured on the palate, there is richness and enough acidity to keep it bright. Interesting in style, I wasn’t sure if I liked it at first but I quickly warmed to it. 89/100

  • 2011 Capital Wines Riesling The Whip Kyeema – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Lemon peel, lime and light florality on the nose. Medium length and well balanced palate. Drinking well already, though the acidity should be enough to let it age well over the next 5-6 years. 89/100

  • 2011 Capital Wines Sauvignon Blanc The Swinger – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Passionfruit and floral aromas. Light bodied, though there is a bit of fruit sweetness to play well against the acidity. Will be best consumed in its youth. 88/100

  • 2011 Capital Wines The Abstainer – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Light nose with rose petal and cherry. Palate is light as well, there is little depth but at least it is dry and what is there seems balanced. 86/100

  • 2010 Capital Wines Merlot The Backbencher Kyeema – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Plum, graphite and some bright red cherries on the nose. Medium bodied palate with more restrained bright red fruits. Not strongly structured but it is drinking well now. 88/100

  • 2010 Capital Wines Shiraz The Front Bencher Kyeema – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Pepper, mixed spices, blackberry and light cherry on the nose. Palate has good length and texture, it’s nicely restrained while still having some generosity of flavour. 89/100

  • 2011 Capital Wines Tempranillo The Ambassador Kyeema – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Raspberry, cherry and graphite on the nose. Savoury palate and though there are some assertive tannins they do not overshadow the fruit. There is good length and I think this would only get better with food. 90/100

  • 2009 Capital Wines Merlot Reserve Kyeema – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Bright and lifted nose of floral aromas, plum, cherry and soft oak. The palate is plush and soft, though the structure is more evident in the mid-palate and it carries well into a lengthy finish. Impressive now and I’d like to see it in 3-4 years. 91/100

  • 2010 Capital Wines Shiraz Reserve Kyeema – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Graphite, smoked meat/game and some spice. I like the savoury style of the palate, though the tannins grip and hold quite tightly. Decent length, but I didn’t really see it being much better than the standard Shiraz in this vintage. 89/100

  • 2011 Capital Wines Riesling Late Picked – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Nice mix of pineapple, quince and mango aromas. Palate is balanced, I would guess at about 40-50 grams per litre of residual sugar, but the acidity balances it nicely. Should age well over 6-7 years. 89/100

Lark Hill

The final cellar door is one that I haven’t visited for 3-4 years after an “interesting” experience on the previous visit, backed by many others telling me they had had similar less than ideal experiences. This was a shame as the wines are usually very good. Recently the son of the owners, Chris has been doing a lot of good work on social media and we decided to give it another go. Chris wasn’t working on the day, but there were no problems with the service. I will mention one negative, which is a tasting fee (unusual to find in Australia) refundable with purchase, implemented earlier this year. I don’t have an issue with the fee as it is rare that I won’t buy at least something at a cellar door, however it isn’t mentioned at all on their website and I find it slightly deceptive to provide cellar door details on the site but not mention the fee.

The winery is certified biodynamic and was the first Australian winery to release a commercial Gruner Veltiner (from the 2009 vintage). Again, these were consistently good wines and I like that they have an aged release available for tasting and purchase.

  • 2012 Lark Hill Viognier – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Peach, ginger, apricot and a nice floral note. Some fruit richness on the palate but it never feels over the top as the acidity cuts through it and it finishes crisply. 88/100

  • 2011 Lark Hill Riesling – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Light florals, lime and minerality on the nose. The palate has biting crisp acidity, it has excellent focus but I do wish it was a bit more generous in its flavour profile. 88/100

  • 2012 Lark Hill Grüner Veltliner – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    White pepper, floral notes and pear on the nose. The spice carries onto the palate, there is good verve and length, it does seem to lack a little spark compared to the 2010 but it is still very good. 89/100

  • 2009 Lark Hill Chardonnay – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Hay, peach and some spicy, slightly nutty oak influence. Palate is a well balanced mix of fruit richness along with some more restrained minerality. 88/100

  • 2010 Lark Hill Pinot Noir – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    A pretty nose of cherry, spice and rose petals. Balanced on the palate, it has medium intensity red fruit along with some more earthy savoury elements. Good for drinking now and over the short-medium term. 89/100

  • 2010 Lark Hill Shiraz Viognier – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Pepper, cherry/kirsch as well as some charcuterie characters. Palate is spice driven, though some black tinted fruit comes into play as well. Good length and a good wine. 89/100

  • 2005 Lark Hill Exaltation – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Mint chocolate, cherry, raspberry and some subtle earth. The palate is medium bodied, there is very good balance between some red fruit and the resolving tannin structure. Drinking well now but should continue to do so over the next 5-6 years. 90/100

  • 2010 Lark Hill Riesling Auslese – Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
    Honey and quince with lime aromas. Palate is quite sweet, there is some spice to it but perhaps needs some more acid to lift it. 87/100

Another month and another great tasting with a regular tasting group. Beaujolais is something I was unsure about before the tasting – I’ve had ones bordering on great but never one that has blown me away and I don’t really get the hype – unfortunately the tasting didn’t push me off the fence either way just yet, but it was an excellent chance to try this variety of wines side by side and compare to a couple of Australian efforts.

The last two flights of Gamay were served blind, as well as the three Australian reds immediately following.

  • 2009 François Chidaine Vouvray Pétillant – France, Loire Valley, Touraine, Vouvray Pétillant
    Lime and pear drive the nose, there is also an earthy and slightly oxidative edge to it, adding interest. The palate is cleaner and delivers good freshness through acidity. 88/100

  • 2005 Domaine Thomas Sancerre Le Pierrier – France, Loire Valley, Upper Loire, Sancerre
    Lemon, hay, light honey and floral aromas. The palate shows honeyed development with decent length. Drinking well now and over the next couple of years. 89/100

  • 2010 Domaine du Vissoux / Pierre-Marie Chermette Fleurie Les Garants – France, Burgundy, Beaujolais, Fleurie
    Nicely perfumed on the nose, with cherries and violets and lots of raspberry influence. The palate is quite lithe, though there are hints of sweet fruit in the background. 88/100

  • 2010 Domaine du Vissoux / Pierre-Marie Chermette Brouilly Pierreux – France, Burgundy, Beaujolais, Brouilly
    Strong floral impact on the nose with violets and roses, there is some liquorice and iron, with meaty elements as well. Medium bodied palate, with grip through the tannins. The palate is mostly savoury in nature, though there is light sweet fruit lurking. 89/100

  • 2010 Domaine du Vissoux / Pierre-Marie Chermette Moulin-à-Vent Les Trois Roches – France, Burgundy, Beaujolais, Moulin-à-Vent
    There is good depth to the nose here – lots of earth elements then violets, tobacco and raspberry contributing. The palate is impressively structured, with spice and minerality giving interest and lifting the wine. Seems more serious than the other two 2010s from this producer that I tried alongside, and I enjoyed it a great deal. 90/100

  • 2010 Julien Sunier Régnié – France, Burgundy, Beaujolais, Régnié
    The nose is pretty and appealing, though there is complexity to it as well – with strawberry, floral notes, stalks, cherry/kirsch and raspberry. The palate is light-medium bodied, the appealing bright fruit characters carry on from the nose. Delicious right now and really enjoyable for its style. 91/100

  • 2010 Coudert Fleurie Clos de la Roilette – France, Burgundy, Beaujolais, Fleurie
    Charcoal, pepper and blackberry on the nose. The acidity on the palate sticks out ever so slightly, disrupting the line and balance. Still decent, but fell behind in comparison to many of the other wines on the night. I’ve had this before and liked it much more then, so I’m not sure what went wrong here. 86/100

  • 2010 Domaine Chignard Fleurie Les Moriers – France, Burgundy, Beaujolais, Fleurie
    Another wine with a strong floral element to the nose, the background aromas are of earth, spice and light stems. Bright acidity mingles with light but juicy red fruits on the palate. Another wine that is enjoyable right now, but for me it was behind the Sunier in interest. 89/100

  • 2008 Jean-Claude Lapalu Brouilly Vieilles Vignes – France, Burgundy, Beaujolais, Brouilly
    Funky nose – with iron, earth, game and cinnamon. The palate is more fruit forward, with good acid supporting. 88/100

  • 2010 Coudert Brouilly – France, Burgundy, Beaujolais, Brouilly
    Raspberry, black pepper and cherry aromas. The palate is medium bodied but it is neither overly bright nor having great depth or drive. Good but no more. 86/100

  • 2006 Daniel Bouland Côte de Brouilly Cuvée Mélanie – France, Burgundy, Beaujolais, Côte de Brouilly
    Violets, spice and earth on the nose. The palate tends too far towards being overly extracted for my taste, with the tannins also prominent. 86/100

  • 2010 Jean-Marc Burgaud Morgon Côte du Py Javernières – France, Burgundy, Beaujolais, Morgon
    Stalks, blackberry, dark floral notes and light oak influence. At first I was impressed with the structure on the palate, but there is very good fruit weight and a core of minerality and the balance is excellent as a result. For me this was one of the wines with better length on the night and I thought it had good potential to improve with time. 91/100

  • 2010 Jean-Marc Burgaud Morgon Côte du Py “Réserve” – France, Burgundy, Beaujolais, Morgon
    Cherry, light cinnamon, violets and an element of game. The palate is approachable, with plush fruit and well integrated bright acidity. I think there is the potential and structure to age well over the medium term even though it is good now. 89/100

  • 2010 Eldridge Estate Gamay – Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Mornington Peninsula
    Stood out in this blind flight as being the Australian entry. Aromas of coconut, cherry, vanilla and a smidge of pepper. The extra fruit weight on the palate gives it away, though there is less acid and tannin than many of the other wines tonight. Despite its origin being fairly obvious side by side, I still quite enjoyed it. 88/100

  • 2006 Domaine Piron & Lafont / Piron-Lameloise Chénas Quartz – France, Burgundy, Beaujolais, Chénas
    Rubber, caramel and vegemite – quite awful on the nose. The palate is less offensive, but it is short and lacking in depth. I’m unsure if this was a sound bottle, but I did not like it.

  • 2009 Domaine des Terres Dorées (Jean-Paul Brun) Beaujolais l’Ancien le Buissy – France, Burgundy, Beaujolais
    Smoky, with game and cherry elements. Acid and tannin are at the forefront, though there is some decent fruit weight, as well as good length. I was left somewhat indifferent to it, though there was no specific issue. 88/100

  • 2011 Clos du Tue-Boeuf Cheverny – France, Loire Valley, Upper Loire, Cheverny
    Extremely stalky, with hay and a wheatgrass note in the background. The palate is lean, but it has a little bit more fruit than the nose. This was too far into the green spectrum for me. 82/100

  • 2011 Sorrenberg Gamay – Australia, Victoria, North East, Beechworth
    Orange peel, roses, spice and a little bit of mint. The palate is an interesting mix of spice and sweet red fruit – this is very different in style to most of the other wines tonight, but I liked it. 88/100

  • 2002 Yeringberg Pinot Noir – Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Yarra Valley
    Cherry and stalks, with light forest floor character. The palate is nicely balanced, with savoury elements and sweet fruit combining well. Drink over the next 5 years. 89/100

  • 2002 Yabby Lake Vineyard Pinot Noir – Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Mornington Peninsula
    Floral nose, with mint, soot and cherry notes. The palate is fairly smooth, but there is a lack of depth and it finishes much too short, especially for a wine and producer with this reputation. 87/100

  • 2005 Yarra Yering Barbera – Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Yarra Valley
    Menthol, cinnamon, smoked meats and soft blueberry aromas. The palate shows spice and restrained sweet fruit. There are multiple layers to this wine and it finishes with excellent length. I note that the label says it is 15% alcohol, but it doesn’t show. I really liked this and was strongly impressed. 91/100

  • 1975 Fritz Haag Brauneberger Juffer-Sonnenuhr Riesling Auslese – Germany, Mosel Saar Ruwer
    Golden coloured. Pear, honey, orange peel and a very light nutty aroma on the nose. The palate is poised, with sweetness but also a lightness and wonderfully well integrated acidity that carries the wine into a medium-long finish. Continued to lift and improve with time in the glass, if I had any more of these I would be looking forward to trying it again in 6-7 years or more as it continues to develop towards its peak. 92/100

  • 2010 Fritz Haag Brauneberger Juffer Riesling Auslese – Germany, Mosel Saar Ruwer
    Very pretty floral aromas along with slate, tropical fruit and lemon in support. The palate has excellent fruit intensity with abundant sweetness and the acid structure to keep it driven. Rich and delicious in a fruit forward phase. Drink it now or give it significant time for further rewards. 91/100

  • 1983 Schloss Plettenberg Winzenheimer Rosenheck Riesling Auslese – Germany, Nahe
    A nose of spice and honey, with slate and a light ginger note. The palate exhibits great balance, with appealing sweetness and cleansing acidity combining to give the wine that quality where you really look forward to the next sip. I thought this had slightly less depth than the Fritz Haag, but it was delicious in its own right. 91/100

  • NV Henriques & Henriques Madeira Malmsey 10 Years Old – Portugal, Madeira
    Complex nose of vanilla, raisins, caramel, almond and walnut, with just a light spirity lift. With the same complexity on the palate, there is sweetness and a softness to it as well as excellent length. 90/100

Paris - Eiffel Tower - Le Jules Verne

Dinner at the 1 Michelin star, Alain Ducasse operated, Le Jules Verne.

The restaurant is situated on the second level of the Eiffel Tower, 150 metres above ground. From my pre-trip research it receives mixed reviews, swinging wildly between being excellent and an abominable tourist trap. I was hesitant to commit, but in the end decided that the experience would probably be worth the risk.

We had our concierge book a table as soon as reservations for our desired date opened, 3 months in advance. The request for a window table is one that I am sure the restaurant continually receives, and we were lucky to have our request granted – giving us a view towards Les Invalides in the East and to the South East down the Parc du Champ de Mars and Ecole Militaire. We were seated with daylight still in force, and as the sun set and the lights of the city started to come up, accompanied by soft rain against the window, the decision to dine here seemed worthwhile.

The restaurant has a private elevator between the ground and second floor, which did prove useful as the public elevators were reduced in number due to maintenance, resulting in long lines to ascend and return. There is also a small set of stairs from the restaurant where you can visit the second level and then return via the same stairs to the restaurant.

In general the food was good to very good. Highlights for me were: the “Green asparagus from Provence and morel mushrooms, yellow wine sauce” which was just a stellar dish of simple ingredients, heightened by how well they worked together and the “Bresse poultry breast with tarragon, spring vegetables” which continued the same theme of complimentary ingredients that weren’t complicated for the sake of it. The “Wild strawberry and mango contemporary vacherin” was brilliant as well, even though I would have thought I’d prefer the “Tower bolt” which was good with its contrasting textures, but there flavours of the vacherin won out.

The service was mixed, wavering between the professional standard expected of this venue and a few interactions where it was evident that it would be much easier for the staff if we would stop bothering them. I’ll also note that a question via a couple of emails after our return to Australia went unanswered, which is in stark contrast to other venues that have gone to lengths to assist in answering questions even though we were departed tourists with no immediate expectation to return.

I would recommend it as a once-off experience, despite the high cost which was 210 euro per person for the dinner degustation plus wine. The prices at lunch excluding the weekend tend towards being more reasonable. The food is generally very good and did hit some high notes, and the view is simply brilliant.

Wine

We had one bottle of wine here, the 2009 Domaine Ramonet Les Enseignères from Puligny-Montrachet. Despite being a “village” level wine, this punched well above its designation (and vintage reputation as well!). A powerful and complex nose of florals, citrus, wax and minerality. The palate continues the impression of fruit power, the ample richness is brought together with good acidity/minerality and fine length. I enjoyed drinking this right now in its life, it is immediately appealing and I think well balanced as it stands. 91/100

Food Photos

Amuse-bouche – Gougères

Amuse-bouche - Gougères

Amuse-bouche – Petit pois

Amuse-bouche - Petit pois

Homard de nos côtes en Bellevue, sucs de cuisson en sabayon et caviar gold – Bellevue-style local lobster, sabayon and Gold caviar

Homard de nos côtes en Bellevue, sucs de cuisson en sabayon et caviar gold -  Bellevue-style local lobster, sabayon and Gold caviar

Asperges Vertes de Provence et morilles étuvées, sauce au vin jaune – Green asparagus from Provence and morel mushrooms, yellow wine sauce

ASPERGES VERTES de Provence et morilles étuvées, sauce au vin jaune - Green aspargus from Provence and morel mushrooms, yellow wine sauce

Blanc de Turbot à la plancha, poireaux et coquillages liés au beurre d’algue – Pan-seared turbot, shellfish and leeks thickened with a delicate seaweed butter

Blanc de TURBOT à la plancha, poireaux et coquillages liés au beurre d’algue -  Pan-seared turbot, shellfish and leeks thickened with a delicate seaweed butter

Suprême de Volaille de Bresse à l’estragon, légumes de printemps en beaux morceaux, vrai jus – Bresse poultry breast with tarragon, spring vegetables

Suprême de VOLAILLE DE BRESSE à l’estragon, légumes de printemps en beaux morceaux, vrai jus - Bresse poultry breast with tarragon, spring vegetables

Vacherin Contemporain fraises des bois/mangue – Wild strawberry and mango contemporary vacherin

VACHERIN CONTEMPORAIN fraises des bois/mangue - Wild strawberry and mango contemporary vacherin

l’Écrou au Chocolat et praliné croustillant, glace noisette – Tower bolt, dark chocolate praliné, hazelnut ice cream

L’ÉCROU AU CHOCOLAT et praliné croustillant, glace noisette - Tower bolt, dark chocolate praliné, hazelnut ice cream