A quick get together at Borelli’s Italian Restaurant in Epping. The restaurant was good for what it is, a small local place that has food with good flavour and large servings, with fairly priced meals (for us it was around $50 AUD per person for three courses and tip) and corkage at $4 a bottle. Most importantly, it was centrally located for the people attending this get together. We had an interesting little mix of wines on the night with a couple of them standing out at the end.
Pol Roger Brut 1996 - (Champagne, France):
A nose of green apples, citrus, some minerals and a touch of yeast but seemed to have softened in intensity since I last tried it in December 2004. There was a slight musty character that reminded me of a similar character on the 1988 Dom Perignon that I had at the French wine dinner at Marque I but I don’t think it was corked (nor did anyone think the Dom corked), it can be hard to tell sometimes though. A glass left to the side for a few hours didn’t seem to have any obvious level of taint to it. The palate had some nice texture to it and a cleansing wave of acidity across the length. A bad bottle or not, I still thought it was a nice wine.
88/100
Leeuwin Estate Art Series Chardonnay 1996 - (Margaret River, Western Australia):
Citrus peel and roasted nuts on the nose. Generous flavour on the palate and the length was good except for a weird bitter echinacea like character on the mid to back palate. Seemed quite developed - not as good as a previous bottle that I had late last year. Based on this bottle and even the one previous, I’d been drinking it over the next couple of years.
86/100
Paul Jaboulet Domaine de Thalabert Crozes-Hermitage 1997 - (France):
Cherry, liquorice, stalks, iodine and tar. Tannins and oak well integrated on the fairly sappy palate. Drinking pretty nicely at the moment, I don’t think it would benefit from much more age.
87/100
E. Guigal Hermitage 1997 - (France):
Blackberry, liquorice, dark berry fruits, dark chocolate. Again the slight sappy green element to the palate, but not as pronounced as with the Jaboulet. Structure, tannins and length seemed to be slightly better than the Jaboulet. A nice wine that will probably be a bit nicer with a few more years in bottle.
88/100
Castagna Genesis Syrah 2002 - (Beechworth, Victoria):
Pepper and spice with background apricot as well as bright raspberry and cherry aromas, there were some floral notes coming through as it just started to open up. I didn’t think the viognier too overt (although if you hate it, it is certainly there in the background). Palate exhibits some excellent texture and structure. Needs another 5+ years to really shine.
91/100
Parker Estate Terra Rossa First Growth 1994 - (Coonawarra, South Australia):
Lots of blackcurrant and cassis, smoke, hints of slightly roasted vegetables and capsicum. Palate is smooth and the components seem well integrated, but it surprisingly has very little secondary development as yet. Very good now and should probably get better if everything stays balanced while it develops complexity.
92/100
Following in the footsteps of the successful first French Wine Dinner at Marque and the moderately successful Australian dinner at Atelier came a dinner earlier this month with mostly the same group of people, at the famed Tetsuya’s restaurant in Sydney. The number of awards this restaurant has received is too long to be listed here, but it has been in the news recently as being awarded the fifth best restaurant in the world for 2006 by the UK based “Restaurant Magazine” (it was fourth in 2005).
I hadn’t been to Tetsuya’s previously, but my expectations were set very high (often a recipe for disaster).
Our group were the first to arrive at the restaurant at 6:30pm (as well as being the last to leave 7 hours later at 1:30am!) and we were given a quick tour including viewing the kitchen and one of the two wine cellars. We were informed that on Friday nights, there are 55 members of staff working for a restaurant that seats just 90 people. We had managed to secure one of the private rooms, the only downside to this being that our view of a small rock garden was not quite as nice as the two main rooms that look out onto a lovely traditional Japanese garden.
Allow me to say that this was by a large margin, the best dining experience of my life so far.
The service was flawless, with the pouring of each set of wines and the arrival of the next course timed to perfection. Our assigned waiter was professional yet also friendly; I imagine he is probably adept at changing his style depending on the people he is serving. There were the small touches like the staff taking our list of wines and printing a personalised menu with the wines and the courses for each person.
The food is faultless; the blend of natural flavours and textures is simply breathtaking. There was not a single course during the entire menu that I thought was anything less than amazing. There was no attempt at pretension or trying to set new extremes about the dishes, just a lesson in letting the flavour of the food take centre stage.
The cost is something that I imagine people baulk at, all together it was $250 AUD per person, this included the degustation menu ($180), the optional cheese plate, corkage ($20 per bottle) and an automatically added 12% service fee. I think it is something that you need to experience to understand that it is worth every single cent. For me, this was a dining experience that was a level above everything else in Sydney, we are lucky to have some excellent restaurants here, but we are genuinely blessed to have Tetsuya’s.
Giving this place a score seems almost like sacrilege, like trying to give a score to a beautiful work of art or trying to rate the memorable moments of your life. 100 points? 110? It doesn’t matter. Simply perfect.
–
Bread with Truffle Butter
Gazpacho with Yoghurt and Basil Sorbet
Pol Roger Sir Winston Churchill 1988 - (Champagne, France):
Fine bead. Intense nose of apple, cinnamon, quince and toast. Superb texture and balance on the palate. This bottle was probably drinking close to its peak. 95/100
Krug Vintage 1989 - (Champagne, France):
Again showing a very fine bead. Nose seems slightly more restrained and youthful than the Pol but exhibited some earthy, mushroom and truffle, mixed nuts and spice aromas. Powerful intensity on the palate but retains exceptional balance and stunning length. Drinking nicely now, but I would love to see it with some additional age and complexity. 95/100
Tartare of Tuna on Sushi Rice with Avocado
Tuna Marinated in Soy and Mirin
Soft Smoked Ocean Trout with Asparagus
Marinated NZ Scampi with Chicken Parfait and Walnut
Maximin Grunhauser / C. von Schubert Abstberg Auslese #56 Riesling 1995 - (Ruwer, Germany):
Youthful in colour. Initially very sulphurous but this started to blow off after some time in the glass to reveal pear, light minerality, rose petals and other floral scents. A slight sweetness tempered by a splendid core of acidity. The finish lingers and leaves you satisfied. 93/100
Zind-Humbrecht Gewürztraminer Grand Cru Goldert 1997 - (Alsace, France):
A burst of power on the nose that really made people sit up and take notice, furious swirling of glasses ensued. A few “wows” were uttered and the opinions seemed generally positive, that was, until people actually started to taste it.
The nose was rich, ripe and interesting with clove, honey, apricot, preserved peaches, lychee, turkish delight and a dash of botrytis. I didn’t find the alcohol too prominent on the nose, but if you were in any doubt as to the high %, a sip was all it took. Palate is alcoholic and has the same rich, ripe characters as the nose, with a harsh bitterness on the back-palate. It felt like the elements of the palate were fighting for attention rather than existing in harmony.
86/100
Confit of Petuna Tasmanian Ocean Trout with Konbu, Daikon and Fennel
Ravioli of Queensland Spanner Crab with Tomato and Basil Vinaigrette
Domaine Francois Raveneau Grand Cru Valmur 2000 - (Chablis, Burgundy, France):
Oyster shells, a touch of funky cheese, sea salt, and some soap initially, but with time in the glass the cheese and soap started blowing off to show more minerals, chalk, grapefruit and floral notes. The palate acid structure is close to flawless. A wine of superb focus, elegance, depth and class that is only going to get better with additional age.
93/100
Domaine Bonneau du Martray 1985 - (Corton-Charlemagne, Burgundy, France):
Aromas of baked cheese soufflé and blue cheese as well as honey and butterscotch. The nose is better than the palate which is short, flat and exhibits unbalanced acid. A shame since other reports have good bottles of this drinking at their peak now.
86/100
Twice Cooked De-Boned Spatchcock with Braised Daikon and Bread Sauce
Domaine Rousseau Clos St. Jacques 1990 - (Gevrey-Chambertin, Burgundy, France):
On the nose - beetroot, plum, cherry, sap, some stalks and some subtle oak. The palate proves joyous to drink - balanced, concentrated, with wonderful length and plenty of interest to keep you coming back for another taste. Must be one of the best red wines from Burgundy I have experienced thus far.
94/100
Domaine Rene Engel 1989 - (Grands-Echezeaux, Burgundy, France):
A nose of earth, undergrowth, mixed spices, sour cherry, with floral and perfumed notes. An elegant, silky-smooth palate with good length. I thought that this perhaps just lacked a spark of magic, and suffered a bit by being next to the Rousseau, on any other night it could have been a star. 91/100
Grilled Wagyu Beef with Asian Mushrooms and Lime Jus
Chateau Latour 1971 - (Pauillac, Bordeaux, France):
An impressive intense nose of cedar, smoke, ash, herbs and roast vegetables. The palate shows all components well integrated and maintaining excellent balance and flavour profile. Classic mature Bordeaux. This bottle was at its peak and was drinking very well. 94/100
Chateau Cheval Blanc 1982 - (St. Emilion, Bordeaux, France):
Seductive, intriguing, complex nose - truffles, earth, liquorice, mocha, smoked smallgoods. A palate of supreme silkiness and rich, dense, youthful restrained power. Legendary length. I was lucky to take the quarter glass remaining in the bottle home with me, and the next night it was drinking just as superbly. Perhaps just a shade behind a magnificent 1985 Cheval Blanc that I was fortunate to have a few months ago but still fantastic. 96/100
Selection of Cheese for two
Chateau La Mission-Haut-Brion 1985 - (Pessac-Leognan, Bordeaux, France):
Blackberry, blackcurrant and cassis on the nose. Some unresolved fine tannins on the palate. Seems youthful, but I wonder if it has the structure to improve further with age. A tough bracket of wines to be a part of and may have shown better if not in that level of company. Very good but not great. 90/100
Chateau Lafite-Rothschild 1986 - (Pauillac, Bordeaux, France):
An alluring, layered nose that delivered something different with each sniff - floral notes, cherry, cedar, tobacco, flint, pencil shavings and a slight yeastiness. A palate that is intensely powerful, yet oozes finesse and class. Excellent balance and length - it could well be a wine to be blown away by in 10+ years time. 96/100
Chateau Leoville-Las Cases 1990 - (St. Julien, Bordeaux, France):
A wild nose of brambly blackberry, black olives, ash, herbs, mint, some mulch and a fair amount of oak lingering in the background. A tightly coiled palate promising so much potential. Lots of pure sweet fruit on the gorgeously long palate. Was sacrificed too young (but it went to a good cause!).
94/100
Beetroot and Blood Orange Sorbet and Strawberry Shortcake
White Truffle Ice Cream with White Beans and Dates
Chateau Suduiraut 1990 - (Sauternes, France):
Orange gold in colour. Unknown to the bringer of the two half bottles, both had been “reconditioned in 2005″ by the Chateau. Nose showed apricot, orange peel, marmalade and almonds. Harsh acidity essentially ruins the palate and the wine thins out and almost tastes weedy on the mid and back palate. Nose seemed overblown and the palate lacked any semblance of balance. 84/100
Zind-Humbrecht Clos Windsbuhl Selection de Grains Nobles Pinot Gris 2001 - (Alsace, France):
A sparkling, golden yellow in colour. A complex nose of honey, peaches, botrytis, apricot, pear, spices and creme brule. Palate had good clarity and depth of flavour. Supreme concentrated richness and sweetness but there is a core of acid in the background slightly struggling to keep up. No doubt a crowd pleaser, and almost certainly the best Pinot Gris I’ve ever had 
Will it age? I’m not sure it will, but I’m also not sure it needs to since it is a joy to drink right now. 96/100
Floating Island with Praline and Vanilla Bean Anglaise
Petit Four
Chateau d’Yquem 1971 - (Sauternes, France):
A deep gold orange in colour. Initially smelt alright but degenerated into raisins and burnt toast. Disjointed and oxidative palate. Cork was soaked through and crumbled on extraction. A poor bottle. NR/100
Chateau Coutet Cuvée Madame 1971 - (Sauternes, France):
Almost the same golden orange in colour as the d’Yquem. Intoxicating, rich aromatic nose of botrytis, caramel, honey, marmalade, apricot, lemon and lime. Intense and complex on the palate with acid still present and tempering most of the sweetness. A very good wine, and it was fitting that we should go out on a high note after all the great wines that were shared. If anyone happens to have any of this rare wine, based on this bottle it is well and truly ready as it will ever be to drink. 92/100
